The
ship is installed with YANMAR 6EY18ALW and Mitsubishi MET18SRC, rated power of
615Kw.Shortly after the departure of a certain voyage, NO.1's turbine vibrated
continuously at generator high load (about 430Kw). Switched to No.3 generator,
the turbine vibrated continuously too after a few hours later. The vibration
started soon, even switched to both no.1 & no.3 generators ran together, the
load of No.3 generator is only 300kw. In addition, the scavenging pressure of
the two auxiliary generators was significantly higher before the vibration, but
the exhaust temperature of the two was not improved, and the phenomenon of
rising instead of falling.
It
is only approx. 500 hours from the last turbine overhaul, after all not long,
turbine is disassembled and found that the turbine is very clean, casing is not
dirty, just accumulated on the nozzle ring leaves a layer of different
thickness, where the airway narrower convex up high, not very hard, like soil
of grey scale, see the attached pictures. After removing the fouling on the
nozzle ring blade, install and retest, the vibration phenomenon is eliminated.
The inspection records showed that the turbine overhaul
of the auxiliary engine was frequent: the turbocharger of NO.1 generator was
disassembled and inspected 4 times in one and half years (about 5300hours),the running
time is only 500 hours since last inspection; the turbocharger of NO.2
generator was disassembled and inspected 4 times in one years (about 3500hours)
the turbocharger of NO.3 generator was disassembled and inspected 6 times in
one and half years (about 5600hours), and the last two times have only been
separated by about 500 hours.
In addition, after the latest overhaul for the
turbocharger NO. 2 generator, scavenging pressure relative to the low before
the overhaul some low (by about 0.02 MPa), but the overall temperature is
abnormal much high, engineer had to rarely use it during the voyage, just used as
at berth.
It is easy to understand the vibration happened to
working under high load if dirty plugging. But why does the vibration occur at
relatively low loads? More surprisingly, the scavenging pressure is obviously
higher before the surge, but the exhaust temperature rises instead of falling.
Why? In addition, what is the reason that the turbine vibrated in a short
period of time, has to frequent inspection? However,How to explain the exhaust temperature of no.2 increased
abnormally after turbocharger disassembled and inspection.
The reasons
for the above questions are as follows:
Compared with other generators, the YANMAR 6EY18ALW
accessory can be made so "small and exquisite", no doubt increase the
power of the single cylinder by turbocharger. Therefore, no matter the load is
high or low, its operation is very dependent on the state of turbocharger, plus
scavenging pressure has a relatively large influence on the exhaust
temperature.
However, the scavenging pressure is not as high as
possible in the use of the rated matched turbocharger and engine.
Because, after clean and in good condition of the turbocharger,
in the course of usage, based on the same load, the higher the scavenging
pressure indicates that the turbine speed is faster, usually also means that
the narrower exhaust gas port (that is,
the turbine will be dirtier). So, the pressure of front exhaust manifold (i.e.,
the exhaust back pressure)will be also higher. Meanwhile, because the engine
has a larger angle of inlet and exhaust overlap (80 °), therefore, exhaust back
pressure is equal to the scavenging back pressure.
On the one hand, as the turbine is more and more dirty,
scavenging back pressure is more and more high, It pushes the turbocharger
works at high speed high back pressure even if on lower load, once the load
changes slightly, it is extremely easy to vibrate. This is also the reason why
"under high load, the turbine has a continuous vibration", gradually
develops to "relatively low load, there will also be a vibration ".
On the other hand, more and more dirty, despite the
scavenging air pressure is higher and higher. (note: scavenging air pressure is
relative increased to exhaust port of the narrowing, but after reaching a peak,
will begin to decline, more and more low), at the same time, exhaust back
pressure is becoming more and more high. The quality of the air conditioning
depends on the pressure difference between scavenging pressure and exhaust back
pressure, not scavenging pressure. Therefore, in the case of both increasing at
the same time, the air exchange effect may not be better or even worse. This is
also the reason why the scavenging pressure of the auxiliary engine is
obviously higher before the turbine vibrates, but its exhaust temperature is
not improved, even the phenomenon of rising instead of falling.
Obviously, for this engine, if the scavenging pressure
is significantly increased during the usage of turbocharger, but the exhaust
temperature is not decreased correspondingly, or even to converse, then it
means the turbocharger should be disassembled and cleaned. Otherwise, the turbocharger
may starts to vibrate soon.
The vibration can be solved by removing and cleaning
the turbocharger. Of course, the cleaning methods and procedures and
installation precision must meet the related requirements of the specification.
Otherwise, if the cleaning is improper, it may be counterproductive, or make
the vibration happen again very soon, or make the exhaust temperature rise
abnormally.
As mentioned above, the drag of the internal exhaust
passage directly affects the scavenging back pressure. Therefore, the
demolition inspection and cleaning of turbocharger should be treated
differently according to different situations:
1. There is no doubt that the scale accumulation on the
turbocharger must be completely removed.
2. The deposition on the nozzle ring must also be completely removed to
ensure smooth and smooth gas passage. In this way, even if the efficiency
slightly reduced relatively, scavenging pressure decreases, but the scavenging
back pressure is relatively lower, which had little impact on air exchange quality,
so, for the effect of exhaust temperature is little; On the contrary, if the
cleaning is insufficient, although it has little influence on the quality of
air exchange and temperature discharge, it will certainly shorten the overhaul
period of turbine.
3. For the scale accumulation on the turbocharger
casing, a light grinding and smoothing should be adopted to ensure the
appropriate clearance. Otherwise, the gap is too big, although relatively lower
exhaust back pressure, but air leakage from clearance will increase
substantially,reducing efficiency of turbine, the scavenging pressure drop too
much, the air exchange quality was also affected by the larger, most likely
would result in higher exhaust temperature anomalies.
To sum up, the turbocharger has to be overhauled
frequently, the main reason is that poor quality fuel oil, diesel engine
long-term low load operation, and poor combustion cause parts such as
turbocharger nozzle ring carbon deposition, and maintenance of nozzle ring
"clean enough" thoroughly; The scavenging pressure of no.2 generator has
been relatively low since the last overhaul, but the exhaust temperature has
been abnormally high, most likely due to the "too clean" of the turbocharger
casing.
In a word, the operation of YANMAR 6EY18ALW auxiliary
generator is very dependent on the operation state of turbocharger. Therefore,
the usage and maintenance of turbine cannot be taken lightly.
Of course, it must be mentioned that the overall
exhaust temperature of the auxiliary engine is high or the turbocharger vibates,
which is also closely related to the technical condition of the air cooler and
the fouling of the inlet pipe of the cylinder head. Generally, the more severe
the air cooler's air side or inlet pipe is blocked, the higher the exhaust
temperature will be, and the higher the back pressure of the turbine will be
and the more likely it will be to cause vibration.
At present, many ships use a central cooling system.
Air coolers use fresh water to cool them. However, it is common for bulk
carriers, which often carry loose coal or ore, more chance to get fouling on the gas side of air cooler. The air
side of the auxiliary air cooler is seldom equipped with instruments to monitor
the pressure drop. Therefore, it is not easy to find out whether there is dirty
plug. Therefore, don't be misled by some superficial phenomena. For example,
the inspection shows that the surface of the air cooler core is clean, or the
air temperature after the air cooler is normal, etc. These phenomena do not
really indicate that the air side is clean. If the overall exhaust temperature
of the auxiliary machine is high, or if the turbine is not very dirty, the vibration
will occur again. Before the problem is solved, do not give up the inspection
and cleaning of the air side of the air cooler. Even if the problem cannot be
completely solved, it will at least help to reduce the exhaust temperature and
will never be in vain. No doubt, this applies to all types of main or auxiliary
engine.
Note: the technical status of auxiliary engine
cylinder, valves, nozzles or fuel oil pump, as well as the influence of oil
injection, timing of inlet and outlet or temperature scavenging on the exhaust
temperature are not discussed in this paper.
No next